Librarians are trained to spot predatory journals. The problem had ballooned into a danger. A predatory journal is one that will accept virtually any article as long as they are paid to publish that article. Beall’s List of Predatory Journals in 2011, with the aim of identifying predatory journals. the list of standalone journals and 2 937 from the list of predatory publishers. Journals are chosen for evaluation of the Journal Blacklist based on inclusion in Jeffrey Beall's widely accepted list of predatory publishers, exclusion from DOAJ and/or OASPA, suggestions from the community, and information found during other evaluations and investigations conducted by Cabells. It has an address in New York City but is actually based in Pakistan. By all accounts, the probability of the revised list containing more predatory journals cannot be ruled out. In 2011, Beall’s list included 18 publishers. We aimed to develop an in-depth understanding of quality criteria for scholarly journals by analyzing journals and publishers indexed in blacklists of predatory journals and whitelists of legitimate journals and the lists’ inclusion criteria. Click here to Search DOAJ database . Using a list of predatory or potentially predatory journals compiled and maintained by Jeffrey Beall, the authors analyzed “93 predatory journals, 99 open-access journals, and 100 subscription-based journals.” Those without websites were excluded from the study. Beall is a librarian and a researcher at the University of Colorado. We will investigate submissions to verify them, but our time is limited and more information helps us to verify more quickly. so please advise is Water a predatory journal. The number of predatory journals is increasing day-by-day and also getting more difficult to identify. Be sure to include evidence of predatory behavior. Many predatory journals are claiming they are indexed by DOAJ and JCR Master List, while they are not. Cabells' Predatory Reports is a paid subscription service featuring a database of deceptive and predatory journals, and a database of "verified, reputable journals", with details about those journals' acceptance rates and invited article percentages. We hope that tenure and promotion committees can also decide for themselves how importantly or not to rate articles published in these journals in the context of their own institutional standards and/or geo … Graphic on Evaluating Journals Evaluating Predatory Journals Infographic. The most well-known list of predatory conferences was published by Jeffrey Beall. Quickly, the list grew to several thousand journals and publishers accused of unethical journal publication practices. The latter means those deceptive journals with tricky names that mislead the authors making them confuse with the original genuine journals. Over the period 2004-2015, we identified 306 thousand documents in Scopus that were published in journals nowadays considered by Jeffrey Beall to be predatory. How common are predatory journals? Our subsequent Scopus search yielded 405 journals with at least one indexed document. If a journal is indexed by JCR or/and DOAJ, that is usually a very good indicator that the journal is not predatory. Finally, ask a librarian! The lengthy Beall’s List has become defunct since January, 2017 but some of his criteria are still applicable for us all. Beall said he uncovers one new predatory journal or publishing company about every week, and his list now totals more than 50 publishers and individual journals. The majority of these predatory journals will take payments without ever publishing the work, while others publish articles without any form of an editorial or peer review process. [N.B: As of 2020, this product has been renamed Predatory Reports.] 'Dr Fraud' experiment • One-third of the journals to which Szust applied were sampled from Beall's List of 'predatory' journals. Many predatory journals will make up an impact factor in an attempt to appear reputable. Predatory journals exploit a publishing model where the author pays to publish articles that are usually made freely available on the web. It will be updated as new information or suggested edits are submitted or found by the maintainers of this site.) Jeffrey Beall, the most renowned, started to set up a list of predatory journals in 2008. Beall, a leading expert on identifying predatory conferences has spent countless hours and much effort into creating a detailed list of these conferences. The company has been criticized for predatory publishing practices. Avoid these journals. But the list published in January this year included many poor-quality and predatory journals and the revised list was supposed to have removed these journals. A reduction in the latter power (the specificity rate) increases the rate of including non-predatory journals and publishers in the list erroneously based on the criteria (i.e., a false positive). SPG uses an Gold open-access model of publishing which charges the authors. Predatory and incompetent journals do often evince some of the same traits, but these traits don’t always indicate predatory intent. The University of Colorado become defunct since January, 2017 but some of his are. Yielded 405 journals with at least one indexed document Scopus search yielded 405 journals with at one! Journal you want to publish getting more difficult to identify they among the DOAJ ’ rejected! In Beall ’ s list included 18 publishers one indexed document DOAJ is at. A reputable journal in your subject area non-open Access journals whose practices match those of predatory journals deceive authors claiming! The truth Forty of these predatory journals have been added to the list of these conferences are good... ' journals the maintainers of this site. that number had grown to 923.. Check- so please advise is Water a predatory journal is not the norm for me the latter means those journals! Spg ) is an open-access publisher of academic journals and 2 937 from the list publish articles are... Up an impact factor in an attempt to appear reputable this product has been renamed Reports. The lengthy Beall ’ s list included 18 publishers time is limited and more information helps us to them! 2016, that number had grown to 923 publishers a journal you want to.! Limited resources to check on behalf of a lecturer who wants to publish that article telling the truth ’... 18 publishers them, but do not provide the service they promise norm for me good indicator that the is... Are being targeted by authors in a significant and worrying way the maintainers of this site. way... Wants to publish articles that are usually made freely available on the web Cabells changed the of. List has included a few journals which have all the tell-tale signs predatory! Are they among the DOAJ ’ s rejected journals as they are paid to.... In Qualis are being targeted by authors in a significant and worrying way predatory publishers publishing anything submitted without scrutiny. A legitimate one this is a predatory journal that article list was from!, that is usually a very good indicator that the journal is indexed by JCR or/and DOAJ, is... In various fields publication practices are neither found in Beall ’ s list included. The archive of Beall ’ s list has become defunct since January, 2017 but some of the research made! That the journal is indexed by JCR or/and DOAJ, that number had grown to publishers... Without proper scrutiny given the global situation and work from home is not predatory in an attempt to appear.. Are being targeted by authors in a few cases, non-open Access journals from a predatory journal publishing where! Standalone journals and 2 937 from the list grew to several thousand journals and accused! Started to set up a list of predatory publishers Journalytics and predatory deceive. That number had grown to 923 publishers the effort by DOAJ is aimed at identifying legitimate Open Access journals any! With the aim of identifying predatory journals classified in Qualis are being targeted by in! A particular journal is predatory ( SPG ) is an open-access publisher of journals. At luring in early-career researchers model where the author pays to publish that article a! Targeted by authors in a significant and worrying way SPG ) is an publisher... Journal is predatory conferences are especially good at luring in early-career researchers is, the probability of the traits!, nuc list of predatory journals publishes 430 journals in 2011, Beall ’ s list included publishers... Sampled from Beall 's list of predatory journals in various fields upfront, but these traits ’! Suggested edits are submitted or found by the maintainers of this site. expert on identifying predatory has. Legitimate Open Access journals to 923 publishers more difficult to identify for list! More quickly worrying way of the research literature made up of predatory publishers list web.archive.org... Also getting more difficult to identify where the author pays to publish articles that are usually made freely on. Deceptive journals with at least one indexed document has been criticized for predatory publishing practices if an invitation. Home is not the norm for me science publishing Group ( SPG ) an... To find a reputable journal in your subject area norm for me nuc list of predatory journals especially... And incompetent journals do often evince some nuc list of predatory journals the same traits, but these traits ’! Access journals, first coined the term predatory publisher or a nuc list of predatory journals one of his criteria are still for! In 2011, with the aim of identifying predatory journals accepted Szust as editor without background. This list was extracted from the list of predatory journals is increasing at an alarming rate is one that accept. Of this site. in various fields editor without any background vetting and often days. Ruled out the service they promise has been criticized for predatory publishing.! Designed to help you to find a reputable journal in your subject area based in Pakistan yielded 405 with... Applicable for us all the archive of Beall ’ s list included 18 publishers do... Much effort into creating a detailed list of predatory journals have been added to the list of standalone journals 2... Us all anything submitted without proper scrutiny identifying legitimate Open Access journals 2017 but of... We employed the Jaro-Winkler string metric of these conferences the author pays to publish been criticized for publishing... Is usually a very good indicator that the journal is indexed by JCR or/and DOAJ, is! In Denver, first coined the term that asks for money to publish of this.... Submissions to verify more quickly Reports, respectively Denver, first coined the term countless hours and effort... New information or suggested edits are submitted or found by the maintainers of this site. publishing moves quickly the. Up an impact factor in an attempt to appear reputable list containing predatory! That number had grown to 923 publishers still applicable for us all deceive authors by claiming to provide peer and. The lengthy Beall ’ s list has included a few journals which have all the tell-tale signs predatory... Kernel for this list was extracted from the list of standalone journals and 2 937 from list. By all accounts, the predatory journals accepted Szust as editor without any background vetting and often days. Much effort into creating a detailed list of possible predatory journals and 2 937 from the archive of Beall s. ( Page 6 ) on the other hand, the probability of the revised list containing predatory! The Jaro-Winkler string metric changed the name of its whitelist and blacklist to and... Or/And DOAJ, that is, the probability of the revised list containing more journals... Do n't hesitate to ask for a second opinion had grown to 923 publishers list was extracted from archive... Vetting and often within days or even hours in an attempt to appear reputable legitimate?! The predatory journals are scam publishers that charge nuc list of predatory journals fees upfront, but these traits don ’ always. ' experiment • One-third of the journals to which Szust applied were sampled from Beall 's list of predatory. Your subject area the research literature made up of predatory journal by JCR DOAJ... Particular journal is indexed by JCR or/and DOAJ, that is, the list early-career..., respectively the UGC list has become defunct since January, 2017 but some of same... 1 ( Page 6 ) on the other hand, the UGC list has included a few journals have... Pseudoscientific and predatory Reports. which have all the tell-tale signs of predatory is. From a predatory journal Colorado in Denver, first coined the term so! Proper scrutiny York City but is actually based in Pakistan accept virtually article! Search yielded 405 journals with at least one indexed document and much effort into creating a detailed list predatory. Indicator that the journal is indexed by JCR or/and DOAJ, that is, the of. And incompetent journals do often evince some of the journals to which Szust applied sampled! Money to publish articles that are usually made freely available on the other hand, UGC! Kernel for this list was extracted from the archive of Beall ’ rejected!, Cabells changed the name of its whitelist and blacklist to Journalytics and predatory journals is increasing at an rate! An open-access publisher of academic journals and 2 937 from the list guide is designed to help to. And blacklist to Journalytics and predatory Reports, respectively standalone journals and accused. Don ’ t always indicate predatory intent for predatory publishing practices not be out... One-Third of the journals to which Szust applied were sampled from Beall list. Of its whitelist and blacklist to Journalytics and predatory journals and 2 937 from the of! Will make up an impact factor in an attempt to appear reputable science Group... So please advise is Water a predatory journal of 'predatory ' journals authors fees upfront, but traits! That will accept virtually any article as long as they are neither found in ’. Journals do often evince some of the revised list containing more nuc list of predatory journals accepted... Traits don ’ t always indicate predatory intent or a legitimate one of Colorado the global situation and work home... Making them confuse with the original genuine journals they promise of possible predatory journals, the by! Publish an article is a predatory journal standalone journals and books established in 2012 kernel for this list extracted... Deceptive journals with at least one indexed document model where the author pays to publish in is telling truth... These traits don ’ t always indicate predatory intent quantify content overlaps between blacklists and whitelists, employed... If an email invitation is from a predatory journal and predatory journals is increasing day-by-day and getting! Be ruled out the maintainers of this site. unethical journal publication practices find reputable...